|
The
Article 32 investigation was called to order at 0939,13 June 2007.
Mr.
Francis W. Wolf, a civilian, was telephonically called as a witness by
the defense, was sworn, and testified as follows:
DIRECT
EXAMINATION
Questions by Captain Hur:
Q. Mr.
Wolf, would you please state your full name for the record?
A. Yes,
sir. Francis William Wolf.
Q. And
what is your current status with regards to being in the military or
not?
A. I am
currently a civilian.
TC [Maj
Erickson]: All right, Mr. Wolf. The defense has called you, and it is
their direct now.
IO:
Lieutenant Colonel Cosgrove.
Questions by Lieutenant Colonel Cosgrove:
Q. This
is Lieutenant Colonel Cosgrove. Can you hear me?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Okay, you are coming in clear. Let me just get one thing straight as a
formality. Is it okay if we call you Sergeant Wolf, or what would you
like to be called?
A.
Whatever is easier, sir. It doesn't matter to me.
Q. I am
going to call you Sergeant Wolf, that is what you are referred to in
the documents, okay?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Let's get started. First of all, you were a member of Kilo Company in
19 November 2005?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. We
have heard testimony earlier from a Sergeant Laughner. Do you know who
that is?
A. Say,
again.
Q.
Staff Sergeant Justin Laughner?
A. Was
that the NCIS?
Q.
Sergeant Laughner, and perhaps you don't remember him. He was the NCO
of the HET Team?
A. Oh
yes, yes, yes.
Q. Do
you know who I am talking about now?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. He
described going out on a second QRF from the firm base at about 0800
with you and Captain McConnell. Do you recall that?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. You
were a member of that team?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Were
you the squad leader then of second squad?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. And
that would be 3d Platoon?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. The
same platoon that Lance Corporal Sharratt was a member of?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Who
were the other squad leaders?
A. Of
my platoon?
Q.
Well, no. The other platoon, and you recall Sergeant Wuterich was a
squad leader?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. And
Corporal Sanchez was another squad leader?
A. He
was the squad leader of 3rd squad.
Q. Do
you recall launching out with that second QRF?
A. It's
been a long time, sir. Pretty much, I remember getting called out on
-- there was an IED, followed by an ambush and we were to step off and
reinforce that squad and basically help in that area.
Q. Can
you approximate how long after the IED that you gathered up everyone
and launched out on foot?
A. My
guys were premature to just the actual detonation. I would say,
probably, no more than five to ten minutes by the time we actually
stepped off.
Q.
Again, when Sergeant Laughner testified and we had a diagram that
showed that your squad took, generally, a route that went West of the
IED site. Do you recall that?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. As
you were traveling West down towards the IED site, do you recall
hearing any small-arms fire?
A. I
remember as we were moving South, we could hear small-arms fire, sir.
Q. You
are out of the Marine Corps, now, but you obtained the rank of
Sergeant. How long had you been in the Marine Corps?
A. I
have been in the Marine Corps for 4 years with a voluntary extension.
Q. How
many deployments did you participate in?
A. That
was my second.
Q. And
the first one was in Fallujah?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. So
you had seen a lot of combat?
A. More
than most, sir.
Q. Can
you tell the difference between AK-47's and M-16fire?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. How
so?
A. How
so? There is a distinct sound from an AK-47, sir. You can establish
which is which. I can't really explain it, I guess.
Q. So
when you say you heard small-arms fire as you were travelling South
from base, can you describe what weapon system you recognized?
A. I
remember hearing -- I can't tell you, exactly. I remember it sounded
like, to me, that there was AK fire, and that was the first shots that
I heard. That is pretty much -- and I heard, like, a MAG firing what
sounded like a grenade.
Q.
Okay. Let me read you a line from an NCIS interview that you gave on
27 July 2006 and tell me if it refreshes your recollection at all?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Specifically, you, Sergeant Wolf, heard AK-47's and M-16fire. Wolf
also thought that he heard RBK and RPG fire. Is that accurate?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Did
you have the radio in the squad?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. You
could hear the traffic?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. In
that same statement, you described it as being of high intensity. Can
you describe what you mean by that?
A.
There was just a lot of chatter coming from 1st Squad, sir. And also
there was another squad that had been launched out right before us,
because we had the secondary QRF. They were also trying to make their
way down to the site, and they were on the radio, also. There was a
lot of traffic going on between the two squads at the time.
Q. Now,
do you recall receiving more fire as you got closer to Chestnut?
A.
Like, when we were heading down there, from the best I can remember,
yes. We had heard fire.
Q.
Specifically, do you recall hearing what you thought was sniper fire?
A. Yes,
sir. We had what I thought was sniper fire coming at us.
Q.
Describe that in more detail. How would you think, or how would you
know that you were receiving sniper fire?
A.
Whenever the rounds come at you, sir, the sound of a Dragonov sniper
rifle is pretty clear that it is coming towards your direction. And
when we were moving south probably about two blocks from, I think it
was Route Chestnut, which was the road that 1st Squad was on, we had
fire that was intended in our direction, which caused me to put my
guys in roof top positions.
Q.
Again, in that same statement, you mentioned a Dragonov sniper rifle.
Is that a weapon that you heard fired before?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Fired at you?
A. Yes,
sir. That is what I believed it to be at the time.
Q. That
is what you believed was firing at you at the time?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Do
you recall seeing rounds impacting in your vicinity?
A.
There was one round, sir, I though might have been an impact. I am not
positive because it happened so fast. Once I heard the round, I
started moving my guys into position. It's been a long time.
Q. I
understand. Just testify to the best of your recollection, okay?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Regardless, you deployed your Marines to take cover in two separate
houses?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. And
that was based on your belief that you were taking fire?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. At
some time thereafter, did you see and engage two military age Iraqi
males?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. That
was when you were still with Sergeant Laughner and Captain McConnell?
A. Yes.
They were with my other team. I was with a different team at the time.
Q.
Those two military age males, what was suspicious about them and their
movement?
A. They
way they were moving, sir. I remember this part clearly. They were
bounding just like we would if we were under fire to break contact.
They were bounding and over lapping like, kind of, a leapfrog measure
away from, kind of, in a south-western direction, which put them right
at us. Where they were coming from was exactly where we had heard the
shots.
Q.
Okay. Anything about the way that they were dressed gave you
suspicion?
A. Sir,
the way they were dressed, you can't use that as a significant way to
pick out an enemy over there. They all dressed the same, and that's
their whole deal. They dressed the same to blend in.
Q. What
about anything that either of them were holding?
A. One
man was holding -- this was about 600 meters out when I first started
to notice. One man was holding a gun, or what looked like one from the
length of it, and that probably is what it was.
Q. So
you, yourself, fired five or six shots at these two individuals?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. And
others within your squad fired at these two individuals?
A. Say
again?
Q.
Others within your squad fired as well?
A. One
other man, sir.
Q. And
you thought your action and the other that fired, that it was
reasonable to fire at these two?
A. Say
again?
Q. You
thought it was reasonable to fire at these two?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Why?
A.
Because of the moving, and also movement towards the individuals. We
had also laid down about three or four warning shots in their
direction in the situation, just to try to get them to stop for their
own safety, and for our safety. And once they continued to come, I
thought we had no choice but to engage the individuals. So myself and
one other man engaged the two individuals.
Q.
After that engagement, did you find yourself in a house with an
injured Iraqi male?
A. Say
again?
Q. I am
just trying to do it sequentially. Did you find yourself in a house
with an injured Iraqi male that eventually was Med Evac'd?
A. Yes,
sir. That was one of the individuals that we engaged.
Q. That
was one of the individual that we just talked about, the two Iraqi
males?
A. Yes,
sir. We moved down there to check the individual out.
Q. And
the other one continued to run on?
A. Yes,
sir. We never found anything as far as where the other individual
went.
Q.
While you were at the house waiting for Med Evac did you hear or did
you witness the air assault on the insurgent house in the East?
A. Say
it one more time for me, sir.
Q. At
some point, did you see the helicopters and fixed wing drop assets on
an insurgents house to the East?
A. Yes,
sir. That was Weapons Platoon.
Q.
Weapons Platoon was being engaged to the East of your position?
A. Yes,
sir. To the Southeast.
Q. Did
you actually see or hear the hell fire missiles being fired?
A. Yes,
sir. They dropped two or three because the first two did not detonate.
Q. Did
you also hear or see the fixed wing aircraft drop500-pound bombs on
that house?
A. I
heard they dropped 500-pound bombs, but I can't remember if I saw the
actual aircraft. But I do know they dropped five hundred pound bombs
on them.
Q. Now,
while you were there, you were still on the radio. Is that right?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Did
you hear the radio traffic about the Scan Eagle and what they had seen
by way of additional insurgent activity?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. What
did you hear?
A. Are
you talking about before weapons or after weapons, sir?
Q.
Before.
A.
Before weapons?
Q. Yes.
A. I'm
sorry. I had so much going on that I wasn't really looking too much
into that. I just knew they released Weapons Platoon or a squad from
Weapons Platoon to move up North towards where 1st Squad was to help
out. And at that time, they got engaged on their way up. And then I
remember Scan Eagle saying they saw three or four insurgents running
to the Southwest.
Q. Now
at some point, were you tasked with joining Lieutenant Kallop and
other Marines to accompany tanks that had been dispatched?
A. Say
that one more time for me, sir.
Q. Did
you end up with Lieutenant Kallop and a couple of tanks to pursue
those insurgents?
A. Yes,
sir, I did.
Q. And
that took you away from Chestnut?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Now
again, you have been in combat before in Fallujah. Is that true?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. How
would you describe, sort of, the pace of that morning there in Haditha
on 19 November?
A. Say
it one more time, sir.
Q. How
would you describe the pace of the action in Haditha on 19 November?
A. It
was definitely a hostile environment, sir. There was no question about
that. I think anybody that was in that city would agree with me. That
was probably one of the worst days. I would put that day up there with
Fallujah, as far as how much -- and we had every squad that was being
sent out was getting IED's or they were getting hit by some kind of
small-arms ambush. It was violence everywhere around you.
Q.
Okay. Let me talk about Fallujah with you a little bit, okay?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. You
were Lance Corporal Sharratt's squad leader in Fallujah?
A.
Squad leader, no, sir. I was his team leader.
Q. How
well, then, do you think you now know Lance Corporal Sharratt?
A. I
know Sharratt pretty good, sir.
Q.
Certainly as his superior in the military, you have a lot of
experience?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. What
is your opinion of Lance Corporal Sharratt as a Marine?
A. As a
Marine, sir, I think he is one of the better ones out there, no doubt
about it.
Q. Why
do you say that?
A. He
is willing to learn. He never bitches, he never moans, he doesn't need
help, and as far as knowing his weapons system, as far as employing
his weapons system, as far as helping other Marines out, and as far as
not being scared and doing what he needs to do, he is, by far, up
there.
Q. You
had the opportunity to clear numerous houses with Lance Corporal
Sharratt?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. You
had the opportunity to take and return fire with Lance Corporal
Sharratt?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Did
you ever know him to act in an unprofessional or untactical way?
A. No,
sir. Sharratt is one of those guys on a mission you tell him to get on
it, whether it be a knock the top or it be a full-blown off the wall
type of mission, he is always on the right level where he should have
been.
Q. He
has good judgment?
A. Yes,
sir. Great judgment as a Marine.
Q.
Okay. Let me talk about two specific instances in Fallujah. There was
a situation where Lance Corporal Sharratt was able to repair your
weapon that had jammed and malfunctioned?
A. He
was always repairing my shit, sir.
Q. But
do you recall one situation that you described as he saved your life?
A. Say
again?
Q. Can
you describe one specific situation where its been described, or you
described, that he saved your life?
A. The
more I think about it, sir, there is a lot more. The one main one that
sticks out in my mind was we were going down Route Henry about two
days before the Hell House, and I was walking along. Me and PFC
Nichols were walking along the left-hand side of the road heading
South, and there was an antitank mine that was rigged to blow for
antipersonnel. And as I went to step, Lance Corporal Sharratt yelled
and grabbed me. And if he hadn't of done that, I probably would have
killed four or five of my own guys there.
Q. You
mentioned in that account, that Hell House. You were apart of that
with Sergeant Major Kasal and Mitchell, Nichol?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Lance Corporal Sharratt was in that house as well?
A. Yes,
sir. He was.
Q. Can
you please describe your participation and Lance Corporal Sharratt's
participation? And I am not sure if everyone knows what the Hell House
is. Can you describe that, as well, briefly?
A. The
Hell House, basically, sir, was the core house of the neighborhood,
basically, than just any other house in the area because there was a
lot of resistance in that area. So we were hitting every house in the
area that was in resistance. It was kind of risky going out, because
you knew you were going to create a pattern, but there was nothing you
could do about it. And we ended up that one of the last houses we had
to clear was set up as an internal ambush for our guys. And I think a
total of seven to ten Marines were injured, one KIA in one house, and
it was a pretty bad house.
Q. And
you were tasked with getting some Marines together to go and rescue
those that were trapped?
A. Yes,
sir. 3d Squad originally hit the house. They had three or four guys
hit and two guys trapped on the inside. And so me and my guys went in
to try to help out.
Q. When
you say "your guys," does that include Lance Corporal Sharratt?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Can
you describe just briefly, again, Lance Corporal Sharratt's action
inside of the house?
A. I
don't really exactly remember. It was pretty chaotic. I was
coordinating Mark 19 and fire support positions. I can't exactly tell
you what I had Sharratt doing, but I know damn well he was doing
exactly what I told him to do with no hesitation. That's all I can
pretty much say, because I can't remember where I exactly had him at.
Q. Is
it fair to say, though, that at that time the surviving Marines were
eventually pulled out of that house?
A. Say
again, sir?
Q. The
Marines were pulled out of that house?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Including then First Sergeant Kasal?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
That's the photograph we have all seen before?
A. Say
again?
Q. That
is the photograph we have all seen before?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. In
Fallujah, you had a Marine under your watch by the name of
Lance Corporal Prentice. Is that true?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Do
you believe you know him well?
A. Yes,
sir, I do.
Q. And
do you know him as his superior?
A. Say
again?
Q. You
know him as his superior?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. You
are not friends with him, right?
A. No,
sir. I mean, I am friends with all of my Marines, sir, but nothing
like, you know.
Q.
Understood. What is your opinion of Lance Corporal Prentice as a
Marine?
A. As a
Marine, sir, I don't think he is -- he's not a very good Marine, sir.
Q. Why
do you say that?
A. He
is just one of those guy that you look at that should have never
joined the Marine Corps. He is pretty lazy. He is that Marine that you
can't trust to go out there and police call cigarette butts unless you
are right there on top of him, and that is pretty bad.
Q. Do
you know him to lie to you?
A. He
doesn't lie. Not that he lies a lot, sir, but he definitely does work
to benefit him.
Q. You
said earlier, at least to me, that he is always out for himself. What
do you mean by that?
A.
Exactly what I said, sir. He is always going to do what is benefitting
to him. If it doesn't hurt him and it works for his schedule better,
he is going to do it, regardless of who he screws over in the process.
Q. I am
sorry. I should have told you I walked away for a second. Give me 10
more seconds, all right?
A. All
right.
Q. Let
me circle back for a second to Lance Corporal Sharratt?
A.
Okay.
Q.
Again, you know Lance Corporal Sharratt pretty well?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Spent a lot of time with him in Fallujah, as well asHaditha?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Would you characterize Lance Corporal Sharratt as somebody who likes
to tell stories and exaggerate things?
A. I
think all Marines exaggerate some stories. I don't think anybody is
innocent of that.
Q. In
particular, have you heard, or do you know by reputation or directly,
Lance Corporal Sharratt doing that type of thing?
A. No,
sir. No.
Q.
Generally though, do you believe that all Marines are guilty of that?
A. I
think everybody is, especially Marines. We all have egos.
Q. Like
to make themselves more important?
A. Not
so much that. I think everybody just tries to outdo each other, you
know what I mean? That is good about the Marine Corps. We are all
competitive.
Q. Did
Lance Corporal Sharratt tell you, or did you hear back on 19 November
in Haditha that as a squad of Marines was clearing South to where they
were taking fire, that he went back to the first vehicle and took the
240 Gulf off of the turret?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Tactically, do you feel that was the right move?
A. At
that time, I think it was an absolute awesome move, sir.
Q. Why
do you think it was an absolute awesome move?
A.
Because they were down to about a six or seven man squad, at the time,
and they had three men hurt. You had a HMMWV out there with a 240 Gulf
on it, and you are taking fire. If you just got hit with an IED that
day, you have to look out for secondary IED's, plus you are an open
target out there. If you get the 240 down and you get down there quick
enough, it's safer for you, and it's safer for your guys because now
you're out of the kill zone and you'll be able to suppress the fire.
Q. So
to you, is that an example of Lance Corporal Sharratt doing what is
tactically right?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. And
that has always been your experience with Lance Corporal Sharratt?
A. Yes,
sir. He is tactically -- he is above his pay grade by many levels.
Q.
Again give me ten more seconds, all right?
A.
Okay.
DC[LtCol Cosgrove]: Sir, no further questions.
IO: One
minute. Captain Hur may have some questions for you.
TC[Capt
Hur]: Yes, sir.
CROSS-EXAMINATION
Questions by Captain Hur:
Q. Good
morning, Mr. Wolf. This is Captain Hur.
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. For
consistency, would you mind if I keep calling you Sergeant Wolf?
A.
That's fine, sir.
Q. Now,
you have been given testimonial immunity to testify today. Is that
correct?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. And
you have been given this testimonial immunity so you can testify
without fear of prosecution based on your testimony?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Were
you given this immunity because on your way out to the IED sight on 19
November, you engaged some Iraqi males that were unarmed?
A. It
wasn't just that, sir. It was the combination of how everybody was
going down, just for my own good, and to protect me.
Q. What
were the other reasons that you were given testimonial immunity?
A. I
don't want to get caught up in this shit to be quite honest with you.
Q. Had
you given some statements before that you later on had to correct?
A. No,
sir. Everything that I have known, I told from the beginning because I
believe the Marines did the right thing.
Q. So
your understanding of why you received testimonial immunity was
because: One, you had killed an unarmed man while you were heading out
to the IED site; and two, you didn't want to get in trouble for
whatever testimony you could offer about the event?
A. Say
it again, now.
Q. You
were given testimonial immunity, to your understanding, because: One,
you killed an unarmed man while you were heading out to the IED sight
on November 19; and two, you didn't want to get in trouble based on
whatever testimony you might offer?
A. Sir,
my main thing for getting immunity was I did everything by my ROE when
I did engage that man, and I also did Med Evac him. But considering
the situation and how everything was going down, and considering you
had already put me in the paper as having murder charges against me, I
got the immunity.
Q. Now,
when you arrived at the IED sight, you didn't see any small-arms fire
hit the actual deck while at the actual IED sight?
A. Say
again?
Q. Let
me get a little bit closer. I know it is difficult to hear me over the
phone. When you arrived out to the IED sight, Sergeant Wolf, you did
not actually see any small-arms fire while you were at the IED sight?
A. When
I was at the IED sight with Staff Sergeant Wilders?
Q. Yes.
A. No.
By that time, everything had calmed down.
Q. It
was fairly quiet while you were at the IED sight?
A. No,
sir. They had some stuff going on with a lot of Marines that got hurt
down there. I mean, as far as the radio -- the shooting was done, sir.
But as far as the radio and everything that was going on, it was still
pretty chaotic.
Q. I
understand it was chaotic in other parts of the city, but at the IED
site and the houses surrounding the IED site, would it be your opinion
that it was fairly quiet?
A. At
that time, yes, sir. When I made the link up, yes, sir.
Q. How
long were you out at the IED site for?
A. I
guess, no more than probably ten to fifteen minutes, sir.
Q. And
while you were out at the IED site, you never actually saw any enemy
weapons recovered from any of the supposed dead enemy that happened at
the IED site?
A. No,
sir. I went straight to Staff Sergeant Wilder and requested my guys
give his guys a little bit of time to get some chow and water. I
didn't walk around and survey the area, no, sir.
Q. And
Staff Sergeant told that you his squad had cleared houses where
insurgents used people as shields?
A. Sir,
at that time, he just said that they took fire. Captain McConnell was
there, sir, so I laid back and let them do their thing. It wasn't time
for me to get involved. I just wanted to make sure everybody was okay
-- make sure, mentally, that he was okay.
Q. But
Sergeant Wolf, you said in your -- let me rephrase. You recall making
a July 2006 interview with NCIS. Correct?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. And
everything you said in that interview was true and accurate to the
best of your knowledge?
A. To
the best of my knowledge, yes, sir.
Q. So
in your July 2006 quote, "Staff Sergeant Wuterich's squad cleared
houses where insurgents had used people as shields." That would be a
correct statement?
A. Yes,
sir. I mean, as far as -- there was a lot on my mind when I made that
statement there. So that would be the statement that is going to be
more accurate, because now it has been so long. I have tried to forget
about all of this.
Q. I
understand. It's been almost three years since the incident. Correct?
A. Has
it been that long? It's been a while.
Q. So
would it also be correct if in your July 2006interview with NCIS, you
said quote "Wuterich also told me that they found multiple weapons on
19 November 2005?"
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Do
you recall Staff Sergeant Wuterich telling you that, too?
A. If I
said it then, sir, then it is probably more accurate. I don't remember
much of it anymore, to be honest with you. It was more fresh in my
mind then, so I do remember talking about weapons they had recovered,
yes, sir.
Q.
Earlier, you testified that you remembered Lance Corporal Sharratt had
told you that he had used his 240Gulf machine gun to gain fire
superiority while at the IED site?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Do
you also remember that Lance Corporal Sharratt told you that he had to
use his nine millimeter pistol because he ran out of rounds?
A. I
remember him saying that he had to clear out the houses. To the best
of my knowledge, sir, I don't remember him saying specifically he used
a nine millimeter pistol.
Q. But
if you had said it in your July 2006, quote "Sharratt also told Wolf
he had to use his nine millimeter pistol at some point because he ran
out of rounds," that would be accurate?
A. If
it is in that statement, sir, it is more accurate than right now, yes.
Q. And
Lance Corporal Sharratt also told you that they had found weapons on
19 November 2005?
A. I
can't recall. It's been forever.
Q. But
again, if you said it in your statement, that would be correct?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q.
Let's discuss Lance Corporal Prentice for a little bit. Lance Corporal
Prentice was in Hell House too with yourself and Lance Corporal
Sharratt?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. And
at Hell House, Lance Corporal Prentice did his job, too?
A. He
was in there before I got there, sir. He was in the actual squad that
went in, the original squad that was actually the squad that got hit.
Q. He
behaved appropriately under fire, though, to the best of your
knowledge?
A. His
team leader was one of my good friends just moved about 15 minutes
away from me, sir, and we were actually talking about him the other
day. And he had told me that he had actually pushed him and Carlisle
into the house with them. I don't know, sir. I wasn't there. So I
shouldn't say. It's not really my place to say, because I wasn't with
them in the Hell House.
Q.
Well, it didn't benefit Prentice to risk his life inside Hell House,
did it?
A. Say
again?
Q.
Well, you say Lance Corporal Prentice, to your knowledge, always does
what benefits his interest?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. But
it didn't benefit Prentice to risk his life?
A. That
would not benefit anybody that arrived in Fallujah. Everybody was
there because we didn't have a choice.
Q.
Well, to your knowledge, Sergeant Wolf, would it benefit Lance
Corporal Prentice to make up stories on how to get Lance Corporal
Sharratt in trouble?
DC[LtCol Cosgrove]: Objection.
WIT[Mr.
Wolf]: Would it benefit him? I think with the situation pending, I
don't think it is going to hurt him much.
Questions by Captain Hur continued:
Q. But
you can't see how that would benefit Lance Corporal Prentice?
A. As
far as him --
Q. As
far as him making up stories to get Lance Corporal Sharratt in
trouble?
A.
Yeah. I think it is going to keep his ass home off of deployment. That
is how it is going to benefit him. I know that is how that kid thinks.
Q. So
to your knowledge, Lance Corporal Prentice has avoided deployment
because of his testimony against Lance Corporal Sharratt?
A. That
is exactly how I see it, sir.
Q.
Would it surprise you to learn that Lance Corporal Prentice is
currently deployed in Iraq right now?
A.
Would it surprise me? It would surprise the shit out of me, because
he's that type to do anything he could to get out of it.
Q.
Sergeant Wolf, would your opinion of good military character for Lance
Corporal Sharratt change if you learned that Lance Corporal Sharratt
had executed three unarmed Iraqi males?
A. No,
sir, it wouldn't.
TC[Capt
Hur]: One moment, please. Let me review my notes. Sergeant Wolf, that
is all the questions I have for you right now. Please stay on the line
as the Investigating Officer, Colonel Ware, may have some questions,
as well as other parties, I'm sure.
EXAMINATION BY THE INVESTIGATING OFFICER
Questions by the investigating officer:
Q.
Sergeant Wolf, you are out of the Marine Corps, now. Is that correct?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Are
you staying in the Reserves, or just severed the relationship in
thinking about Reserves?
A. I am
actually thinking about going back in.
Q. This
immunity that you received is from whom?
A. Say
what?
Q. You
described your testimonial immunity. My question is, who is it from?
A. I
don't know, sir. My lawyer is taking care of that.
Q. Is
it in the capacity of civilian? Do you know if the attorney general is
involved in that, or something you were told by the military that you
had immunity?
A. I
want to say it was something to do with General Mattis, sir. My lawyer
has copies, sir. He would know more that than I do.
Q. So
you have to say you are answering the question to the best of your
knowledge without any other problems. Is that correct?
A. Yes,
it is. I mean, it's been a long time. I am trying to remember as much
as I can, and I really don't want to remember it, but, I'm trying.
Q. I
want to just ask you a couple of questions relating to your experience
that you described. You said that you were taught some rules of
engagement and you used them. You follow the rules, but you needed
immunity because of what was happening. I guess there's been some
notoriety of your name in the paper. Is that correct?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. So
you are concerned that even thought you followed the rules, that
members of the media and other people are going to try to make you a
criminal?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Now,
you also described you engaged, what you believed, were two enemies,
and you said you fired warning shots?
A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Why
did you fire warning shots when that is not normally part of rules of
engagement?
A.
Warning shots are not even authorized, sir, and that's why when we had
done that, it was just to try to get them to stop where they were at.
Q. Did
you fire warning shots because you were concerned that others wouldn't
believe you were applying rules of use of force appropriately?
A. Say
again.
Q. Did
you fire warning shots because you were concerned that if you didn't
that others might second guess your use of force?
A. No,
sir. I just thought it was the right thing to do.
Q. So
even though you were taught not to fire warning shots, you did it
because you were trying to avoid having to kill those people?
A. I
was trying to avoid, at all cost, trying to kill those people, sir.
Q. But
under your understanding, the rules of engagement and the use of
force, you were authorized to kill them because they posed a threat?
A. Yes,
sir, I am. That is why we did kill them.
IO:
That is all the questions I have. Any follow up?
DC[LtCol Cosgrove]: No, sir.
TC[Capt
Hur]: None from the government, sir.
IO: Mr.
Wolf, thank you for your testimony. I have just one last question. If
you are required to testify at any further proceedings, are you
planning on leaving the country with employment, or are you going to
be available to be contacted?
WIT[Mr.
Wolf]: I will be right here.
IO:
Thank you. Have a good day.
____________________________
|